| |
|
What to do? - Understand the Options
Treatment of the overweight and obese is a two-step process: assessment
and management. Assessment requires determination of the degree
of obesity and absolute risk status by your practitioner. Management
includes weight control or reducing excess body weight and maintaining
that weight loss as well as instituting other measures to control
associated risk factors. There are many ways to treat obesity and
there are a variety of health practitioners such as: nutritionists,
doctors, exercise physiologists, psychologists and bariatric weight
loss surgeons that can assist in determining the most appropriate
treatment for you. Just remember that every treatment works differently
for each of us and that the primary concern of overweight and obesity
is one of health and not appearance.
We are assuming that you are obese or morbidly obese and have tried
to change your behavioral factors (diets and exercise) without success
and are interested in treatments that address the biological factors
in your body that are outside your control through weight loss surgery.
By understanding the options you will be better prepared to make
your weight loss surgery treatment decision with the help of an
obesity practitioner of your choosing. (we
can help you find a practitioner if you need one) Obesity is
a chronic disease, your practitioner knows and you need to understand
that successful treatment requires a life-long commitment.
The information provided here is meant only to give you a basic
understanding of the weight loss surgeries available. Your weight
loss surgeon and other physicians are your best resource for information
about the various weight loss surgery procedures they will recommend
to you. Understanding these procedures is necessary if you are to
give what is called "informed consent" for the procedure.
Informed consent is a legal term meaning that you agree that you
have received and understood enough information about a weight loss
surgery's benefits and risks to allow yourself to make a decision
that is right for you. Your surgeon will require you to sign a consent
form before performing your procedure. Before you sign a consent
form, you should have a solid understanding of the change you are
about to make in your life. You should know what you will need to
do to live well after the a weight loss surgery operation. And you
should be informed and aware of the signs or symptoms of complications
which may occur after your surgery.
One way of treating your biological or genetic obesity factors
is through the use of weight loss surgery to promote weight loss
by restricting food intake or interrupting the digestive process.
Gastric bypass surgery, more commonly known as stomach stapling
typically involves stapling off a large portion of the stomach so
that the stomach size is greatly reduced. Celebrities such as singer
Carnie Wilson and TV weatherman Al Roker have helped popularize
weight loss surgery after undergoing successful procedures themselves.
But there are more weight loss surgery options available then just
stomach stapling or gastric bypass, as we will cover below, the
LAP-BAND® System procedure is a reversible alternative that many may consider.
Weight loss surgery is recognized by the American College of Surgeons
and the American Heart Association, and it is endorsed by the National
Institutes of Health and many other prominent medical institutions.
Weight loss surgery could be the best solution for you if you meet
the following criteria:
- You are more than 100 pounds or 100% above your recommended
weight.
A body mass index (BMI) above 40--which means about 100 pounds
of overweight for men and about 80 pounds for women--indicates
that a person is severely obese and therefore a candidate for
weight loss surgery. Weight loss surgery also may be an option
for people with a BMI between 35 and 40 who suffer from life-threatening
problems such as severe sleep apnea or obesity-related heart disease
or diabetes. Please note that the BMI calculator above gives you
a general number, please consult your doctor for a more precise
BMI measurement.
- You have repeatedly tried -- and failed -- to lose weight using
diets, exercise, and behavior modification.
- You have serious associated health-risk factors such as:
- high blood pressure (hypertension)
- heart problems (cardiovascular disease)
- diabetes
- shortness of breath
- swelling of the legs
- joint and back pain
- depression
- sleep apnea
- infertility
- other weight-related conditions
As in other treatments for obesity such as the LAP-BAND® System, successful
results depend mainly on motivation and behavior. Your practitioner,
including behavioral and nutritional professionals, should be part
of a lifelong follow-up plan to ensure your weight loss surgery
remains an effective treatment.
Generally weight loss surgery procedures can promote weight
loss in three ways:
- Restriction - Decreasing food intake
- Roux-en-Y (RNY) gastric bypass (short limb
or proximal)
- Adjustable gastric banding (AGB) (LAP-BAND® System)
- Gastroplasty
- Laparoscopic Sleeve Gastrectomy
- Malabsorption - Causing food to be poorly digested or
absorbed
- Bilopancreatic diversion
- Duodenal switch
- Combination of Malabsorption and Restriction
- Long limb (or distal) gastric bypass
Roux-en-Y Gastric Bypass Weight Loss Surgery
According to the American Society for Metabolic & Bariatric Surgery
(ASMBS) and the National Institutes of Health, Roux-en-Y gastric bypass
is the current gold standard procedure for weight loss surgery.
It is the most frequently performed operation for weight loss in
the United States, accounting for more than 90% of all weight loss
surgeries.
In the Roux-en-Y gastric bypass procedures, a surgeon makes a direct
connection from the stomach to a lower segment of the small intestine,
bypassing the duodenum, and some of the jejunum. A 15 - 60 cc proximal
gastric pouch is created using several staple lines. The proximal
gastric pouch is drained into a segment of the jejunum and "bypasses"
the distal stomach and duodenum. The proximal part of the divided
intestine is then connected to the side of the intestine that was
previously attached to the pouch. The roux limb is that part of
the intestine between the stomach pouch and the connection to the
proximal small intestine.
The difference between short limb (or proximal) and long limb (or
distal) gastric bypass is the length of the roux limb. Long limb
gastric bypass results in more malabsorption than short limb gastric
bypass. The result is sustained weight loss of >50% excess body
weight in over 80% of patients. The surgery can be done laparoscopically
or open. This procedure may be an option for people with a BMI between
35 and 40 who suffer from life-threatening problems for example,
severe sleep apnea or obesity-related heart disease or diabetes.
Roux-en-Y Gastric Bypass Weight Loss Surgery Benefits
- One year after surgery, weight loss can average 65-80% of excess
weight
- After 10 years, 50-60% of excess body weight loss has been maintained
by some patients.
- Associated medical problems, such as diabetes, hypertension,
sleep apnea, joint pain, and heartburn are improved or resolved
in more than 90% of patients
Roux-en-Y Gastric Bypass Weight Loss Surgery Risks
- Because the duodenum is bypassed, Poor absorption of iron, calcium,
and vitamin B12 can result in deficiencies. Metabolic bone disease
can also occur but all these problems can usually be prevented
by vitamin and mineral supplementation but is especially important
for patients who experience chronic blood loss or are prone to
osteoporosis.
- Dumping syndrome can occur as the result of rapid emptying of
stomach contents into the small intestine which usually happens
if too much sugar is consumed. While generally not considered
to be a serious risk to your health, the results can be extremely
unpleasant and can include nausea, weakness, sweating, faintness
and, on occasion, diarrhea after eating.
- The bypass portion of the stomach, duodenum and segments of
the small intestine cannot be easily visualized using x-ray or
endoscopy if problems such as ulcers, bleeding or malignancy should
occur.
- In some cases, the effectiveness of the procedure may be reduced
if the stomach pouch is stretched and/or if it is initially left
larger than 15-30cc.
- Risks of surgery include infection, bleeding, blood clots, leaks,
strictures, and bowel obstructions. In general, the benefits of
gastric bypass outweigh the risks for people with a BMI > 40,
or for people with a BMI of 35-40 and the presence of medical
problems associated with obesity.
Adjustable Gastric Band (AGB) or Laparoscopic Band (LAP-BAND® System)
A Gastric Band (lap band) surgical procedure is a purely restrictive
approach to reducing the capacity of the stomach by which a band is
placed around the upper most part of the stomach giving it the shape
of an hour glass. This band divides the stomach into two portions,
one small and one larger portion. No stomach stapling is required.
The LAP-BAND® System induces an early feeling of stomach fullness, thereby
decreasing food intake. You naturally feel the need to eat less. Any
food you eat will be absorbed by your body at least as well as before
the operation, as your digestive system is not altered in any way.
Weight reduction will instead be achieved by the fact that you
will simply feel the need to eat less. This is because it only takes
a small amount of food for the LAP-BAND® System to give you a true feeling
of appetite satisfaction. The LAP-BAND® System is designed so that it can
be inflated or deflated at any time after the operation to meet
your weight loss requirements, without any further surgery. This
is achieved by injecting a fluid solution into a port placed under
the skin. This procedure may be an option for people with a BMI
between 35 and 40 who suffer from life-threatening problems for
example, severe sleep apnea or obesity-related heart disease or
diabetes.
Adjustable Gastric Band (AGB) or LAP-BAND® System Benefits
Adjustable Gastric Band (AGB) or LAP-BAND® System Risks
- Gastric perforation or tearing in the stomach wall may require
an additional operation.
- Access port leakage or twisting may require an additional operation.
- May not provide the necessary feeling of satisfaction that one
has had enough to eat.
- The band portion of the lap band slips and the small gastric
pouch above the band becomes larger. This can cause a partial
obstruction and vomiting and may require removal of the band.
This problem is prone to occur early after the lap band has been
placed and is more likely to occur if there is repeated vomiting.
Generally a liquid diet is recommended for the first month after
the lap band operation.
- Slower initial weight loss than Gastric Bypass or BPD.
-
Regular follow-up critical for optimal results.
-
Requires an implanted medical device (the lap band).
-
In some cases, the lap band's access port may leak and require
minor revisional surgery.
Gastroplasty (vertical banded) (also known as stomach stapling)
It is a purely restrictive procedure with no malabsorptive effect.
The goal of this procedure is to severely restrict the patient's
capacity to eat certain foods. The vertical banded gastroplasty
creates a small stomach within the regular stomach. In this stomach
stapling procedure, a vertically oriented staple line is placed
high on the right side of the stomach. The outlet is measured and
its size controlled. A mesh band or a silastic ring (flexible, but
inelastic) is placed around the outlet of the pouch to keep the
pouch outlet from stretching.
Aside from the creation of the small pouch there is no significant
change in the gastrointestinal tract. This procedure may be an option
for people with a BMI between 35 and 40 who suffer from life-threatening
problems for example, severe sleep apnea or obesity-related heart
disease or diabetes.
Benefits
- Normal digestive tract order. That allows the nutrients and
vitamins (as well as the calories) to be fully absorbed into the
body.
- After 10 years, studies show that patients can maintain 50%
of targeted excess weight loss.
- Fully reversible.
- Inherently safer operation than the Gastric Bypass because there
is no cutting and sewing of the intestine like in the Gastric
Bypass operation.
Risks
- Usually results in less weight loss than RNY. It does not restrict
intake of high calorie liquids (sweets) and the pouch can stretch
with overeating.
- Stomach Stapling disruption may in the long-term, lead to weight
gain or leakage and/or serious infection. For these reasons, some
surgeons divide the stomach stapling wall of the pouch from the
rest of the stomach to reduce the risk of long-term stomach stapling
line disruption.
- May lead to complications of obstruction or perforation, requiring
surgical intervention.
- Pouch stretching or the restricting band or ring at the pouch
outlet breaking or migrating, thus allowing patients to eat too
much.
Laparoscopic Sleeve Gastrectomy
Laparoscopic Sleeve gastrectomy (LSG) is the restrictive part of the more extensive mixed restrictive and malabsorptive operation, gastric bypass and duodenal switch (GB/DS). It generates weight loss by restricting the amount of food that can be eaten without any bypass of the intestines or malabsorption. With this procedure, the surgeon removes approximately 85 percent of the stomach laparoscopically so that the stomach takes the shape of a tube or "sleeve." This part of the procedure is not reversible. Unlike many other forms of bariatric surgery, the outlet valve and the nerves to the stomach remain intact.
Because the modified stomach continues to function normally there are fewer restrictions on the types of foods which patients can consume after surgery. The quantity of food the patient can consume is greatly reduced. This is seen by many patients as being one of the benefits of the laparoscopic sleeve gastrectomy, as is the fact that the removal of the majority of the stomach also results in the virtual elimination of hormones (ghrenlin) produced within the stomach which stimulates hunger.
This procedure is usually performed on superobese or high risk patients with the intention of performing a gastric bypass or duodenal switch at a later time. The stomach that remains is shaped like a thin sleeve and measures 35-60 cc or less, depending on the preference of the surgeon performing the procedure. The nerves to the stomach and the outlet valve (pylorus) remain intact with the idea of preserving the functions of the stomach while reducing the volume. Note that there is no intestinal bypass or malabsorption with this procedure, only stomach reduction.
Benefits
- No foreign body is used as in the adjustable gastric banding and thus no adjustment is required.
- If weight loss is inadequate, the patient has the option to have the second stage of the operation (gastric bypass or the duodenal switch).
- It does not involve any bypass of the intestinal tract and thus patients aviod the complications of intestinal bypass such as intestinal obstruction, anemia, osteoporosis, vitamin deficiency and protein deficiency.
- For lower BMI patients (35-42) who have complications (inadequate weight loss, band erosion, poor quality of life etc.) associated with gastric banding, LSG maybe a good alternative.
- It also makes it a suitable form of surgery for patients who are already suffering from anemia, Crohn's disease and a variety of other conditions that would place them at high risk for surgery involving intestinal bypass.
- It is one of the few forms of surgery which can be performed laparoscopically in patients who are super obese.
- Better quality of life with less late complications as compaired to gastric banding.
Risks
-
Inadequate weight loss or weight regain is possible with operations that do not include an intestinal bypass. This is true of any form of purely restrictive surgery, but is perhaps especially true in the case of the sleeve gastrectomy.
-
The procedure requires stapling of the stomach and therefore leakage and of other complications directly related to stapling may occur.
-
Patients who are super obese usually require second stage operations in order to lose the rest of the excess weight if their BMI remains larger than 45, although two stages may ultimately be safer and more effective than one operation for super obese patients.
- LSG is not reversible, but it can be converted to a gastric bypass.
- Long-term weight loss results are unknown.
Biliopancreatic Diversion
and Duodenal Switch
The biliopancreatic diversion procedure is less food restrictive
than the RNY. It has two components. A limited gastrectomy (removal
of a 3/4 of the stomach) results in reduction of oral intake, inducing
weight loss. The second component of the operation, construction
of a long limb Roux-en-Y so the anatomy of the small intestine is
changed to divert the bile and pancreatic juices so they meet the
ingested food closer to the middle or the end of the small intestine.
This creates a significant malabsorptive component which acts to
maintain weight loss long term.
From the patient's perspective, the great advantages of this operation
are the ability to eat large quantities of food and still achieve
excellent, long term weight loss results. Disadvantages of the procedure
are the association with loose stools, stomal ulcers, and foul smelling
stools and flatus. To address this problem the duodenal switch is
used, originally designed for patients with bile reflux gastritis.
It allows the first portion of the duodenum to remain in the alimentary
stream thus reducing the incidence of stomach ulcers. When combined
with a 3/4 sleeve resection of the stomach, continuity of the gastric
lesser curve is maintained while simultaneously reducing stomach
volume. A long limb Roux-en-Y is then created. The limb acts to
decrease overall caloric absorption and the long biliopancreatic
limb diverting bile from the alimentary contents, specifically to
induce fat malabsorption. This procedure is claimed to essentially
eliminate stomal ulcers and dumping syndrome and may be an option
for people with a BMI between 35 and 40 who suffer from life-threatening
problems for example, severe sleep apnea or obesity-related heart
disease or diabetes.
Benefits
- Patient can eat large amounts of food and not gain weight.
- A study reported 72% excess body weight loss maintained for
18 years. These are the best results, in terms of weight loss
and duration of weight loss, reported in the bariatric surgical
literature to this date.
- Inherently safer operation than the Gastric Bypass because
there is no cutting and sewing of the intestine like in the Gastric
Bypass operation.
Risks
- Greater chance of chronic diarrhea, stomach ulcers, more foul
smelling stools and flatus.
- Bone Demineralization.
- Higher risk of protein malnutrition.
- Higher chance of micronutrient deficiencies such as vitamins
and calcium.
- Close lifelong monitoring for protein malnutrition, anemia and
bone disease is recommended.
| Restrictive
and Malabsorbtive Procedures |
Long Limb or Distal Roux-en-Y Gastric Bypass (RYGBP-E)
RYGBP-E is a means of achieving malabsorption by creating a stapled
or divided small gastric pouch (restrictive), leaving the remainder
of the stomach in place. A long limb of the small intestine is attached
to the stomach to divert the bile and pancreatic juices creating
malabsorption. This procedure carries with it fewer operative risks
by avoiding removal of the lower 3/4 of the stomach. Gastric pouch
size and the length of the bypassed intestine determine the risks
for ulcers, malnutrition and other effects. This procedure may be
an option for people with a BMI between 35 and 40 who suffer from
life-threatening problems for example, severe sleep apnea or obesity-related
heart disease or diabetes.
Benefits
- A study reported 72% excess body weight loss maintained for
18 years. These are the best results, in terms of weight loss
and duration of weight loss, reported in the bariatric surgical
literature to this date.
- Diminished appetite.
- Weight loss commonly reaches 75% of a person's excess body weight.
Risks
- Dumping is a group of unpleasant symptoms that resembles food
poisoning (nausea, vomiting, diarrhea, abdominal cramps, flushing,
and palpitations) that occurs when simple sugars enter the small
intestine without first being properly digested by the stomach.
- Bone Demineralization.
- Change in the taste of food.
- Since the staples at the top of the stomach completely block
off the lower portion of the stomach and the upper small intestine,
there is no easy way to evaluate these portions of the gastrointestinal
tract should there be a problem at a future time -- such as an
ulcer, bile duct stones, or cancer.
- Higher risk of protein malnutrition.
- Higher chance of micronutrient deficiencies such as vitamins
and calcium.
- Close lifelong monitoring for protein malnutrition, anemia and
bone disease is recommended.
- Anemia.
- Stomal Stenosis.
- Anemia
- Vitamin B12 deficiency.
- Calcium deficiency/osteoporosis.
Disclaimer:
All content is for informational purposes only. Content is not intended
to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or
treatment. The information provided on this site is designed to
support, not replace, the relationship that exists between a patient
and his or her existing physician. The information (including but
not limited to information contained on message boards, in programs,
or in chats) may not apply to you and before you use any of the
information provided in the site, you should contact a qualified
medical, dietary, fitness or other appropriate professional. If
you use information provided in this site, you do so at your own
risk and you specifically waive any right to make any claim against
BCC Internet, its officers, directors, employees, or representatives
as the result of the use of such information.
|